| Badge | Officer | Year Appointed |
| 1 | Harry Padget - 1st Chief | (1923) |
| 2 | Gustave Hartdorn - 2nd Chief | |
| 3 | George Proctor - 3rd Chief | (1951) |
| 4 | Emil Card - 4th Chief | (1955) |
| 5 | Robert Licker - 1st Patrolman | (1958) |
| 6 | Gerald Beatrice - 5th Chief | (1959) |
| 7 | Patrolman Picciotti | (1959) |
| 8 | Patrolman Jennings | (1959) |
| 9 | Don Degraw | (1960) |
| 10 | Patrolman Janulin | (1961) |
| 11 | Marvin Hooey | (1962) |
| 12 | Harlin Blake | (1963) |
| 13 | John Reeves | (1963) |
| 14 | John Mohl | (1965) |
| 15 | Harry Ressland - 6th Chief | (1966) |
| 16 | John Post | (1967) |
| 17 | Paul Kolb | (1968) |
| 18 | Bernard Hudson | (1969) |
| 19 | William DeStefano - 1st Captain | (1969) |
| 20 | Donato Celestina | (1969) |
| 21 | Patrolman Winer | (1970) |
| 22 | Terry Procopio | (1970) |
| 23 | Jay Broschart | (1970) |
| 24 | Frank DeVelez | (1972) |
| 25 | Hank Morrow - 1st Lieutenant | (1972) |
| 26 | Thomas Soules - 7th Chief | (1977) |
| 27 | Walter Mahon | (1977) |
| 28 | John Schaub | (1977) |
| 29 | Robert Rosendale | (1977) |
| 30 | Randy Hackett | (1978) |
| 31 | Richard Roemmele | (1978) |
| 32 | John Peine | (1985) |
| 33 | Charles Quant Sr. | (1987) |
| 34 | Glenn Danzo | 1991- |
| 35 | Ed DeFilippis | (1995) |
| 36 | James MacIntosh | 1995- |
| 37 | Earl Charles | (1998) |
| 38 | Gregory Bogert | 1998- |
| 39 | Kevin Smith - 8th Chief | 1999- |
| 40 | Mike Connington | (1999) |
| 41 | Chris Biro | 1999- |
| 42 | James Clark | (1999) |
| 43 | Gary Keil | 2001- |
| 44 | Robert DiGirolamo | 2002- |
| 45 | Thomas Antonucci | (2003) |
| 46 | Patrick Harden | 2003- |
| 47 | John Barone | 2003- |
| 48 | Charles Quant Jr. | 2003- |
| 49 | Anthony Famularo | 2004- |
| 50 | Travis Roemmele | 2005- |
| 51 | Joseph McDermott | 2005- |
| 52 | Anthony LoPorto | (2006) |
| 53 | Eric Hollenstein | 2007- |